# Critical Journal Appraisal of Literature Reviews in Midwifery: A Practical Guide for Midwifery Students

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/
- Published: 2026-04-29T09:33:51+07:00
- Author: Arofah Firdaus

## Abstract

The ability to perform a critical journal appraisal (CJA) is an essential competency
for undergraduate midwifery students in understanding and applying evidence-based
midwifery practice. This article aims to provide a practical guide for conducting
CJA, particularly on literature review journals in the field of midwifery, with 
an emphasis on the accuracy of topic selection. The method used is a literature 
study and synthesis of various appraisal guidelines from JBI and Cochrane. The discussion
shows that the accuracy of the topic in a midwifery literature review must be assessed
based on five main criteria: (1) relevance to midwifery practice, (2) recency and
comprehensiveness of literature coverage, (3) clarity of the research question using
the PICO framework, (4) representativeness of the database sources, and (5) consistency
between the title, content, and conclusions. This article presents practical appraisal
steps in a table format as well as a case example relevant to student learning. 
It is concluded that mastering CJA on literature reviews not only improves students’
academic skills in English courses but also equips future midwives with the ability
to critically filter scientific information before applying it in midwifery care.

**Keywords:** critical journal appraisal, midwifery, literature review, topic accuracy,
midwifery students

---

## Introduction

In evidence-based midwifery, students are required not only to read journals but
also to critically assess the quality and relevance of a research study. One of 
the fundamental skills in the English course for midwifery is Critical Journal Appraisal(
CJA), which is a systematic process of evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of
a scientific article.

This article aims to guide undergraduate midwifery students in performing CJA appropriately,
focusing on literature review journals. The accuracy of the topic selection in a
literature review is the main determinant of whether a review article is suitable
to be used as a basis for midwifery practice.

## Why Is a Literature Review Important in Midwifery?

A literature review presents a synthesis of various primary studies on a specific
topic. In midwifery, topics such as “the effect of prenatal education on anxiety
in pregnant women” or “the effectiveness of acupressure for labor pain” are often
reviewed in the form of a literature review. The advantage of a review is its ability
to provide a comprehensive overview without requiring the reader to read dozens 
of original articles.

However, not all literature reviews are of good quality. A midwife or midwifery 
student must be able to assess the accuracy of the topic and the methodology of 
the review.

## Criteria for Topic Accuracy in a Midwifery Literature Review

Topic accuracy is the foundation of a good critical appraisal. Below are the aspects
that must be assessed.

### 1. Relevance to Midwifery Practice

The selected topic must address a real clinical question. An example of a good topic
is: “Non-pharmacological interventions to reduce nausea and vomiting in the first
trimester of pregnancy.” This topic is specific, has a direct impact on midwifery
care, and is based on common patient complaints.

### 2. Recency and Comprehensiveness of Coverage

A good literature review should include publications from the last 5–10 years. In
midwifery, practice guidelines change rapidly, for example regarding labor management
or early initiation of breastfeeding. An article that uses outdated literature (
more than 15 years old) without justification should be questioned for its validity.

### 3. Clarity of the Research Question

A precise topic will generate a research question using the PICO format (_Population,
Intervention, Comparison, Outcome_). Example:

 * **P** (Population): Third-trimester pregnant women
 * **I** (Intervention): Pregnancy exercise
 * **C** (Comparison): No pregnancy exercise
 * **O** (Outcome): Duration of the first stage of labor

Without a PICO framework, the topic is often too broad or vague.

### 4. Representativeness of Database Sources

Does the author use only one database, such as Google Scholar? Or have they used
PubMed, CINAHL, and the Cochrane Library? For midwifery topics, the use of at least
two reputable databases is an indicator of topic accuracy because it ensures that
the literature coverage is not biased.

### 5. Consistency Between Title, Content, and Conclusions

It is common to find journals with promising titles, but the content of the review
discusses a different topic. For example, the title mentions “the effect of oxytocin
massage on breast milk production,” but the content is dominated by lactation physiology
without any intervention data. This is a failure of topic selection.

## Practical Steps for Critical Appraisal for Midwifery Students

The following is a simple guide that can be used when reading a literature review
journal for coursework or scientific writing. Step Key Questions 1. Initial screening
Does the title reflect the content and is it relevant to midwifery? 2. Research 
objective Is the aim of the review stated explicitly? 3. Search strategy Which databases
were used? What keywords, and do they match PICO? 4. Inclusion/exclusion criteria
Are the publication year, study types, and language clearly stated? 5. Quality assessment
of sources Did the author critically appraise the summarized articles? 6. Synthesis
of results Are the results presented narratively or statistically (meta-analysis)?
7. Conclusion and recommendations Are the conclusions not exaggerated compared to
the available evidence?

## Case Example: Assessing Topic Accuracy

**Article title (fictional):**
_“Literature Review: The Use of Hypnobirthing to 
Reduce Anxiety Levels in Primigravida Mothers”_

**Appraisal questions:**

 1. Is the topic relevant to modern midwifery practice?
    → Yes, because anxiety in pregnant
    women is a common problem.
 2. Is the research question clear?
    → Fairly clear, but the PICO format is not explicitly
    used.
 3. Did the author limit the publication year?
    → The article only uses literature from
    2010–2015, while the article was written in 2024. → This is a weakness.
 4. Was only one database used (Google Scholar)?
    → Yes, so there is a risk of bias.

**Appraisal conclusion:**
The topic of this article is actually good and relevant,
but the accuracy in selecting the literature is outdated and the search is not comprehensive.
Students should not recommend this article as a main reference; instead, they should
look for a more recent review indexed in PubMed or Cochrane.

## Conclusion

Critical journal appraisal of literature reviews in midwifery requires thoroughness,
especially in assessing the accuracy of the topic. A precise topic must be relevant
to midwifery practice, based on a clear research question, supported by quality 
databases, and consistently reflected from the title to the conclusions. For undergraduate
midwifery students, this skill is not only important for passing the English course
but also serves as a foundation for evidence-based clinical decision-making in the
future.

By practicing reading and critically appraising, students will avoid predatory journals
or misleading literature reviews, and will be able to propose midwifery interventions
that are safe, effective, and appropriate to patient conditions.

## References

Aromataris, E., & Munn, Z. (2020). _JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis_. JBI Global.

Harden, A., & Thomas, J. (2018). _Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions_(
6th ed.). Cochrane.

Polit, D. F., & Beck, C. T. (2021). _Nursing Research: Generating and Assessing 
Evidence for Nursing Practice_ (11th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.

---

## Comments

### By: Shintadreages Sudarso

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3416
- Published: 2026-05-05T11:37:28+07:00

This article provides a clear and systematic guide on Critical Journal Appraisal(
CJA), particularly for literature review studies in the field of midwifery. One 
of its main strengths is the well-structured presentation of appraisal criteria,
including topic relevance, the use of the PICO framework, and the selection of credible
databases. These aspects are highly beneficial for undergraduate midwifery students
in developing their critical thinking skills and applying evidence-based practice.

Moreover, the inclusion of a case example enhances the practicality of the article,
making it easier for readers to understand how to apply the appraisal steps in real
situations. The step-by-step format also improves readability and usability for 
academic purposes. However, the article has some limitations. The methodology is
limited to a literature study without a detailed explanation of the source selection
process, which may introduce potential bias. In addition, the article does not provide
an in-depth application of standardized appraisal tools such as JBI or Cochrane 
checklists, which could limit its usefulness for more advanced academic or clinical
purposes. In conclusion, this article is relevant and useful as a foundational guide
for midwifery students in learning critical appraisal skills. Nevertheless, further
exploration using more comprehensive sources and rigorous methodologies is recommended
for deeper understanding and clinical application.

### By: Windry syifa Annisa

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3414
- Published: 2026-05-03T15:25:55+07:00

This material is well-written, applicable, and relevant for midwifery students, 
particularly in understanding the fundamentals of evidence-based practice. With 
a few additions to methodology and scientific references, this material has the 
potential to become a very powerful guide, even developing it into a learning module
or a journal article worthy of publication.

### By: Azlillah

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3337
- Published: 2026-05-01T09:51:40+07:00

This article explains critical journal appraisal in a clear and easy-to-understand
way. The content helps midwifery students understand how to properly evaluate the
quality and credibility of a journal. It also highlights the importance of selecting
reliable sources to support evidence-based practice. In addition, the step-by-step
guidance provided makes it easier for beginners to follow and apply in academic 
tasks. Overall, this article is useful as a practical guide to improve critical 
thinking and analytical skills in the field of midwifery.

### By: Yupi Jiana Putri

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3332
- Published: 2026-05-01T08:39:01+07:00

After reading this article, I understand that critical journal appraisal is very
important in midwifery practice. The article clearly explains how midwives can evaluate
research articles using criteria such as relevance, accuracy, clarity, and reliability.
I learned that evidence-based practice helps improve maternal and newborn care by
using trustworthy scientific information.
 I also think the article is easy to understand
because it provides practical steps and examples for evaluating journals. The use
of the IMRAD structure helps readers identify the important parts of a research 
article. In my opinion, this article is very useful for students because it improves
critical thinking skills and helps us choose quality references for assignments 
and research. Overall, the article gives valuable knowledge about how to analyze
scientific journals carefully and apply research findings in real clinical practice.

### By: Hughes Syamsinar

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3321
- Published: 2026-05-01T08:06:31+07:00

This paper demonstrates a strong understanding of the importance of Critical Journal
Appraisal (CJA) in evidence-based midwifery practice. The explanation is structured
systematically, starting from fundamental concepts to practical steps, making it
easier for students to follow the logical flow of ideas. The use of concrete examples,
such as the hypnobirthing topic, effectively helps bridge theory with real-world
clinical practice.

In addition, the discussion on topic accuracy criteria—such as clinical relevance,
the use of PICO, and database selection—reflects a solid depth of analysis and aligns
well with current evidence-based practice standards. The emphasis on using up-to-
date and comprehensive literature is also a significant strength, as it is highly
relevant to the rapidly evolving field of midwifery.

Overall, this article is not only informative but also educational, as it equips
students with critical thinking skills in evaluating journal quality. This is essential
to prevent the use of unreliable sources and to support safe and appropriate clinical
decision-making.

### By: Amelia Dwi Indriani

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3299
- Published: 2026-04-30T09:15:56+07:00

This explanation is clear and very helpful for midwifery students in understanding
how to critically appraise literature review articles. It emphasizes that evaluating
a journal is not only about reading, but also about checking the accuracy of the
topic, the quality of sources, and the relevance to clinical practice.

The criteria provided, such as relevance, recency, use of PICO, and database selection,
make the appraisal process more structured and easier to follow. The case example
also helps in understanding how to apply these concepts in real situations. Overall,
this explanation supports students in developing critical thinking and improving
their ability to use evidence-based information in midwifery practice.

### By: Aulia Dinda Widianingrum

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-2/#comment-3298
- Published: 2026-04-30T09:14:19+07:00

This material is well-structured, with a clear flow from the abstract to the conclusion,
making it easy to understand. The topic is highly relevant to midwifery students
in applying evidence-based practice. The appraisal criteria presented are comprehensive
and practical, especially the use of the PICO framework. However, the methodology
needs to be explained more clearly to strengthen its scientific value. Additionally,
adding references would enhance the credibility and academic quality of the material.

### By: Gita Meisya syehan

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-1/#comment-3297
- Published: 2026-04-30T09:10:26+07:00

The material in this article is presented in a systematic and easy-to-understand
manner, especially for midwifery students who are still learning to conduct critical
journal appraisal. The explanation of the importance of CJA in evidence-based practice
is highly relevant and helps readers understand its application in the field of 
midwifery.
 In addition, the presentation of the five main criteria for assessing
topic accuracy is a strong point, as it provides clear and practical guidance. The
article not only explains the concepts but also enables readers to apply them directly
when reading journal articles. Another strength is the inclusion of a case example,
which makes the discussion more concrete. Through this example, readers can clearly
see how the appraisal process is carried out, making it easier to understand. Overall,
this article is very useful as a practical guide for students to improve their critical
thinking skills when evaluating scientific literature, particularly in the field
of midwifery.

### By: Ikha Nurul ‘Ain🪐🌞

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-1/#comment-3296
- Published: 2026-04-30T09:09:32+07:00

This material clearly highlights the connection between academic skills and clinical
practice. The explanation of the five criteria for evaluating topic accuracy is 
relevant and well-structured, especially the use of the PICO framework, which is
essential in evidence-based practice. However, it would be more effective if concrete
examples were included for each criterion so that students can better understand
how to identify an appropriate topic in real journal articles, not just in theory.

### By: Fitri Yulianti

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/critical-journal-appraisal-of-literature-reviews-in-midwifery-a-practical-guide-for-midwifery-students/comment-page-1/#comment-3295
- Published: 2026-04-30T09:09:00+07:00

Critical journal appraisal of literature reviews is an essential skill for midwifery
students, as it helps ensure that the chosen topic is relevant, clearly defined,
and supported by high-quality sources. This skill is not only important for academic
success but also serves as a foundation for making accurate and evidence-based clinical
decisions in the future.
