# Integration of Evidence-Based Practice and Research Novelty in Writing Midwifery Journal Articles

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/
- Published: 2026-05-06T06:24:39+07:00
- Author: Arofah Firdaus

## Abstract

Writing scientific journal articles is an essential skill for undergraduate midwifery
students to disseminate research findings and enrich clinical midwifery practice.
Two main pillars determine the quality of a journal article: the evidence-based 
practice (EBP) approach and research novelty. This article aims to analyze the alignment
between the writing theme and EBP principles, describe strategies for identifying
novelty, and explain the correct use of tenses in academic manuscripts. The method
employed is a literature study and conceptual analysis based on current scientific
writing guidelines. The discussion shows that integrating EBP through the hierarchy
of evidence (e.g., systematic review or randomized controlled trial) and presenting
novelty based on research gaps significantly increases the likelihood of article
acceptance in indexed journals. The use of simple present tense for general statements
and facts, simple past tense for methods and results, and present perfect tense 
for outcomes that remain relevant is recommended. This article concludes that midwifery
students need to practice evidence synthesis skills and problem innovation from 
an early stage.

**Keywords:** evidence-based practice, research novelty, journal article, midwifery,
academic writing

---

## INTRODUCTION

Undergraduate midwifery students at Universitas Muhammadiyah Ahmad Dahlan Cirebon
are required to produce scientific work that is not only procedural but also impactful
on midwifery practice. One important output is a journal article that contains **
research novelty** and is based on **scientific evidence**. Without novelty, an 
article merely repeats existing reports; without strong evidence, the recommendations
provided cannot be clinically justified. Therefore, this article will discuss three
main aspects: (1) alignment of the writing with the theme of EBP and novelty, (2)
strategies for presenting novelty based on research gaps, and (3) the correct use
of tenses in each section of the article.

---

## DISCUSSION

### 1. Alignment of the Writing with the Theme of Evidence-Based Practice and Research Novelty

**Alignment** means the article content consistently reflects the two core concepts.
In midwifery, a paper is considered aligned when:

 * **The research question** is formulated using the PICO format (_Population, Intervention,
   Comparison, Outcome_), for example: “Is oxytocin massage (I) more effective than
   synthetic oxytocin (C) in increasing breast milk production (O) in post-cesarean
   section mothers (P)?”
 * **The literature review** prioritizes sources with high levels of evidence, such
   as systematic reviews, meta-analyses, or clinical guidelines from professional
   organizations (e.g., ACNM or IDI).
 * **The conclusion** is not speculative but directly refers to the strength of 
   the evidence presented.

For example, an article on “The Effectiveness of Prenatal Exercise on Reducing Back
Pain” would align with the theme if the author includes a literature map showing
that previous evidence was limited to cross-sectional designs, then offers a quasi-
experimental study as the novelty. Thus, alignment is not merely about the title
but is visible throughout the entire article flow.

### 2. Evidence-Based Practice and Research Novelty

#### a. Evidence-Based Practice in Midwifery Journal Articles

EBP is the integration of the best research evidence, clinical expertise, and patient
values. In writing an article, students need to demonstrate that their recommendations
are not based on a single case study but are supported by the hierarchy of evidence.
The levels of evidence from highest to lowest are:

 1. Systematic review or meta-analysis of RCTs
 2. Randomized controlled trial (RCT)
 3. Quasi-experimental and cohort study
 4. Case-control and cross-sectional study
 5. Case reports and expert opinion

A good article already cites the level of evidence for each reference used.

#### b. Research Novelty

Novelty does not mean something that has never been discovered anywhere in the world,
but can take the form of:

 * **A new population**: for example, the application of hypnobirthing education
   to pregnant women with a history of recurrent miscarriage in the Cirebon region(
   not yet studied in this population).
 * **A new combination of interventions**: for example, a combination of warm water
   immersion and lavender aromatherapy to reduce pain in the first stage of labor.
 * **A different design or research location**: for example, a mixed-method design
   to explore cultural factors affecting antenatal care (ANC) visits in coastal 
   areas.
 * **Development of local instruments or protocols**: for example, modification 
   of a high-risk-based partograph observation sheet.

To make novelty clearly visible, students must write a _Research Gap_ subsection
in the introduction. Example sentence: _“Several studies have examined the effectiveness
of katuk leaves for enhancing breast milk production, but no study has compared 
them with moringa leaf extract among breastfeeding mothers with undernutrition status
at primary healthcare facilities.”_

### 3. Correct Use of Tenses

The use of tenses in journal articles follows international conventions (IMRaD) 
and must be consistent. The following is a practical guide for midwifery students:
Article Section Dominant Tense Example Sentence **Abstract** Simple present tense(
background & conclusion), simple past tense (methods & results) _This study examines…_(
present). _Data were collected…_ (past). **Introduction** Simple present tense (
general facts, theory) & present perfect tense (previous research still relevant)
_Maternal mortality rate is a key indicator…_ (present). _Several studies have shown
that…_ (present perfect). **Methods** Simple past tense (passive voice is often 
used) _A quasi-experimental design was employed. Participants were recruited from…_**
Results** Simple past tense _The mean pain score decreased from 6.5 to 3.2 _**Discussion**
Mixed: simple present (interpretation), simple past (referring to own results), 
present perfect (linking to other studies) _This finding is consistent with…_ (present).
_Our study found a…_ (past). _Other researchers have reported…_ (present perfect).**
Conclusion** Simple present tense _We conclude that…_, _The implication of this 
study is…_

A common mistake: using the simple future tense (will, shall, would) in the results
or conclusion. In journal articles, predictions are not allowed except in suggestions
for future research.

---

## CONCLUSION

Writing journal articles in midwifery requires undergraduate students to integrate
evidence-based practice and research novelty simultaneously. Thematic alignment 
is achieved when the research question uses the PICO format, the literature review
is based on the hierarchy of evidence, and the conclusion does not overstate the
evidence. Novelty can be demonstrated through a new population, intervention, design,
or location, and must be formulated in a clear research gap. The correct use of 
tenses—especially simple present, simple past, and present perfect—is a technical
skill equally important for meeting the standards of indexed journals. With continuous
practice, students of Universitas Muhammadiyah Ahmad Dahlan Cirebon can produce 
articles that make a genuine contribution to the advancement of evidence-based midwifery
practice.

---

## REFERENCES

Greenhalgh, T. (2019). _How to Read a Paper: The Basics of Evidence-Based Medicine
and Healthcare_ (6th ed.). Wiley-Blackwell.

Hoffmann, T., Bennett, S., & Del Mar, C. (2017). _Evidence-Based Practice Across
the Health Professions_ (3rd ed.). Elsevier.

Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2019). _Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing&
Healthcare: A Guide to Best Practice_ (4th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.

Perry, S. E., Hockenberry, M. J., Lowdermilk, D. L., & Wilson, D. (2018). _Maternal
Child Nursing Care in Canada_ (2nd ed.). Elsevier Canada.

Sastroasmoro, S., & Ismael, S. (2014). _Dasar-dasar Metodologi Penelitian Klinis_[
Fundamentals of Clinical Research Methods] (5th ed.). Sagung Seto.

Universitas Muhammadiyah Ahmad Dahlan Cirebon. (2023). _[Panduan](https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/panduan-editorial/)
Penulisan Artikel Jurnal untuk [Program](https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/pentingnya-website-di-era-ai/)
Studi S1 Kebidanan_ [Guidelines for Writing Journal Articles for the Undergraduate
Midwifery Study Program]. Cirebon: UMA Cirebon Press.

## Comments

### By: Fitri Yulianti

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-2/#comment-3481
- Published: 2026-05-09T08:53:57+07:00

The paragraph is well-structured and effectively emphasizes the importance of integrating
evidence-based practice, research novelty, and appropriate academic grammar in midwifery
journal writing. The ideas are presented logically and are highly relevant for undergraduate
midwifery students in improving the quality of their scientific publications.

### By: Yupi Jiana Putri

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-2/#comment-3480
- Published: 2026-05-08T17:13:08+07:00

This article provides a clear discussion about the importance of writing scientific
journals in midwifery education. The author explains the challenges students face
in academic writing and highlights how structured guidance can improve writing skills.
I think the article is useful because it encourages students to develop critical
thinking, research ability, and scientific communication. The discussion and conclusion
are easy to understand and relevant for health students, especially in midwifery.
Overall, the article gives valuable information and motivation for students to improve
their academic writing competence.

### By: Azlillah

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-2/#comment-3457
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:55:55+07:00

This article provides an insightful explanation about the importance of integrating
Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) and research novelty in midwifery journal writing.
I really appreciate how the author highlights the role of innovation and scientific
evidence in improving the quality of midwifery care. The discussion is clear, relevant,
and very useful for students, researchers, and healthcare professionals. Hopefully,
more midwifery researchers will be encouraged to produce high-quality and impactful
scientific publications after reading this article.

### By: Hughes Syamsinar

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-2/#comment-3456
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:50:07+07:00

This article demonstrates a good understanding of the importance of integrating 
evidence-based practice (EBP) and research novelty in midwifery scientific writing.
The discussion is presented systematically and supported by relevant examples, making
the material easier to understand and apply in academic writing. The explanation
about the hierarchy of evidence and research gaps is particularly useful because
it helps students understand how to develop research topics that are both relevant
and scientifically valuable.

In addition, the section on the correct use of tenses is very helpful for students
who are still learning academic English writing. The guidance based on the IMRaD
structure makes the explanation more practical and applicable in journal article
preparation.

Overall, this article is informative, relevant, and beneficial for improving students’
academic writing skills in evidence-based midwifery practice.

### By: Ikha Nurul ‘Ain🪐🌞

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-2/#comment-3455
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:49:48+07:00

This material is highly relevant and valuable for undergraduate midwifery students,
especially in improving their scientific writing skills. The explanation about the
importance of \*evidence-based practice\* (EBP) helps students understand that research
should be based on strong scientific evidence so that the findings can be applied
effectively in midwifery practice. In addition, the discussion of research novelty
provides insight that a study should not merely repeat previous research, but should
also offer new perspectives or solutions to existing research gaps.

I also find the section on the use of tenses very helpful because many students 
still face difficulties in academic writing in English. The explanation of the appropriate
use of simple present tense, simple past tense, and present perfect tense makes 
academic writing more systematic and aligned with international scientific writing
standards.

### By: Windri sipa annisa

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-2/#comment-3454
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:32:11+07:00

This material explains the importance of writing scientific articles on midwifery
that are based on evidence-based practice (EBP) and possess research novelty. A 
good article should use a PICO-based research question, supported by the highest
level of evidence, and have clear novelty through different populations, interventions,
designs, or research locations. Furthermore, the use of academic tenses must be 
in accordance with the IMRaD structure, such as the simple present for general facts,
the simple past for methods and results, and the present perfect for previous, relevant
research. Overall, this material is useful as a guide for midwifery students in 
writing quality scientific articles that meet the standards of indexed journals.
✨

### By: Lia Sri mulyaningsih

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-1/#comment-3453
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:12:11+07:00

This material explains the importance of research novelty through a clearly written
research gap in the introduction, such as showing differences in variables, methods,
or research locations compared to previous studies. In addition, the material emphasizes
the correct use of tenses in scientific articles based on the IMRaD structure. The
simple present tense is used for general facts and conclusions, the simple past 
tense for research methods and results, and the present perfect tense to explain
previous studies that are still relevant. This material helps students understand
how to write scientific articles systematically, consistently, and in accordance
with international journal standards.

### By: Aulia Dinda Widianingrum

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-1/#comment-3452
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:10:49+07:00

The material provides a clear and systematic explanation of how evidence-based practice(
EBP) and research novelty are integrated in midwifery journal writing. The discussion
about the hierarchy of evidence is especially useful for undergraduate students 
in improving the scientific quality of their articles. The explanation of research
novelty is relevant and practical because it shows that novelty can come from population,
intervention, design, or research location differences. This helps students better
understand how to identify research gaps in midwifery studies. The section on the
correct use of tenses is very beneficial for academic writing practice. The examples
given for each IMRaD section make it easier for students to apply proper grammar
conventions in international journal articles. The article successfully combines
theoretical concepts with practical examples related to midwifery, such as oxytocin
massage, prenatal exercise, and hypnobirthing. This makes the material easier to
understand and more applicable to clinical midwifery research. Overall, this material
is informative, well-structured, and highly relevant for undergraduate midwifery
students. It encourages students to develop critical thinking, evidence synthesis
skills, and innovation in producing scientific articles that contribute to evidence-
based midwifery practice.

### By: Amelia Dwi Indriani

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-1/#comment-3451
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:10:21+07:00

This explanation is insightful and easy to follow, especially for midwifery students
who are learning academic writing. It clearly shows that a good journal article 
should not only present research findings, but also be supported by strong evidence
and clear novelty. The discussion about EBP, research gaps, and the correct use 
of tenses makes the material more practical and relevant for scientific writing.
I also like how the examples help readers understand how these concepts can be applied
in real midwifery research.

### By: Syarifah aisyiah

- Link: https://muhammadiyahciko.or.id/integration-of-evidence-based-practice-and-research-novelty-in-writing-midwifery-journal-articles/comment-page-1/#comment-3450
- Published: 2026-05-07T16:09:45+07:00

This material is very interesting because it explains the importance of writing 
scientific articles based on Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) and novelty in the field
of midwifery. The quality of an article is not only determined by the research results,
but also by the strength of the scientific evidence used.
